Marty and Judd, now friends after the events of Shiloh and Shiloh Season, exchange squirrels and stew as a kind gesture between two friends, but soon realize that Shiloh is still afraid of Judd. After Judd gets into a drunken fist-fight at the bar, he stands accused of murder, which Marty immediately refutes. The two new friends decide to work together to clear Judd’s good name and get Shiloh to trust his first owner once again.